In 2020, the competition regulator proved something most borrowers suspected: the longer you'd been with your bank, the worse your mortgage rate. Six years on, that gap has closed. So we went looking for where the money went - and found it in the one rate almost nobody checks.
The ACCC's Home Loan Price Inquiry put hard numbers on the loyalty tax. Customers with loans three to five years old paid 0.58 percentage points more than new customers. At five to ten years: 0.71 points. Past ten years: more than a full point. On a $250,000 loan, the gap cost roughly $1,400 in the first year alone - and around $17,000 over the life of the loan if you never asked for better.
The gap that closed
Fast forward to the RBA's own September 2026 data, and the story has flipped. Owner-occupiers with existing loans pay 6.20% on average. New borrowers pay 6.22%. The loyalty gap on mortgages has compressed to essentially zero - refinancers shopped around, banks were forced to compete, and the watchdog's pressure worked. On mortgages, at least.
| Measure | Then (ACCC, 2020) | Now (RBA, Sept 2026) |
|---|---|---|
| Mortgage: loyal vs new customers | +0.58 to +1.04 pp | 6.20% vs 6.22% (gap ~0) |
| Savings: base rate, CBA | - | 0.10% |
| Savings: base rate, Westpac | - | 0.10% |
| Savings: base rate, NAB | - | 0.01% |
Sources: ACCC Home Loan Price Inquiry, final report (2020); RBA Lenders' Interest Rates, September 2026; Canstar rate database, 13 November 2026.
Where it moved
Look at your savings instead. The headline rates banks advertise - 5%, sometimes more - almost all hang on conditions: deposit this much monthly, make no withdrawals, grow your balance. Miss one, and you fall to the base rate. And the base rates are where the loyalty tax now lives: 0.10% at CBA and Westpac, and 0.01% at NAB - a rate that has not moved through all five of the RBA's 2026 rate hikes, even as the same banks charge over 6% to lend that money out.
The economics are not subtle. Commonwealth Bank reported $10.9 billion in profit this financial year, with a net interest margin of 2.05% - the gap between what it pays for money and what it charges, defended in part by millions of accounts earning almost nothing.
What to actually do
None of this requires a finance degree. Find your savings account's base rate - it is usually several pages into the product sheet, in the small print. Compare it to the unconditional rates on the market (as of November 2026, at least one major lender pays 5.75% with no conditions at all). If your base rate starts with zero, the gap between what you earn and what your bank earns on the same money is the loyalty tax - you are just paying it from a different account now.
General information only - not personal financial advice. Your circumstances are yours; the math is everyone's.
Future versions of this article may link to savings accounts we rate highly. Some of those links may be affiliate links that earn Veylit a commission at no cost to you. They will never change which accounts win - an account with no affiliate program beats one with one, every time the numbers say so.
ACCC - Home Loan Price Inquiry, final report (December 2020): loyalty gaps of 0.58 / 0.71 / 1.04 percentage points by loan age; ~$1,400 first-year and ~$17,000 lifetime cost on a $250,000 loan.
RBA - Lenders' Interest Rates, September 2026: owner-occupier variable, outstanding 6.20% vs new 6.22%.
Canstar - savings rate database, 13 November 2026: base rates CBA 0.10%, Westpac 0.10%, NAB 0.01%; market-leading unconditional rate 5.75%.
Commonwealth Bank - Annual Review FY26: net profit after tax $10,911m; net interest margin 2.05%.